Thursday, June 25, 2009

Post #7

I was recently introduced to the following website for Project New Media Literacies: http://newmedialiteracies.org/. A point that this website makes, and something that I have been considering lately, is about a recent shift in teaching media literacy. The focus has gone from only teaching students how to critically analyze messages aimed at consumers, to also teaching students how to participate in a culture that creates material for others to consume. This is the idea of the participatory culture in which we are all capable of adding our own thoughts, pictures, and artwork to the public realm pretty easily. And the research shows that kids are doing just that. In order for kids to be literate participants of this culture, the website suggests a few skills that teachers might want to focus on in the classroom. Therefore, the following assignments are based on some of these skills and the idea of the participatory culture.

Assignment #1 – Keeping a Blog

Objectives for Learners:
-Students will know the technologies necessary to start and maintain a blog.
-Students will understand the social norms and writing styles essential to successfully maintaining a blog.

Anticipatory Set:
-Students will search the web for 3-5 blogs noting similarities and differences between them. Students will then share the blogs in a small group setting and discuss what constitutes a successful blog. In a large group, we will debrief and establish class criteria for successful blogging.

Lesson:
-Students will be instructed through a variety of mini lessons how to set up and maintain a blog using a secure server provided by the school. Students will ensure that they have access to all class blogs.
-Students will maintain the blog through a unit of study on short stories. On most days, students will use the blog to post their thoughts about the reading including summaries, questions, connections to the outside world, etc. Also, students will read and post on all class blogs to encourage dialogue about stories. The posts will be required homework due before the in-class discussion on the reading.
-Other assignments that might be posted on the blog include researched information about the author, time period of the story, allusions found in the story, etc.

Assessment:
-I will comment on students’ blogs providing informal ongoing assessment.
-I will use a rubric to score quality of posts and to hold students accountable for posting on other class blogs.

Assignment #2 – Credible Sources

Objective for Learners:
-Students will be able to distinguish between credible and untrustworthy information found online.

Anticipatory Set:
-I will show examples of credible websites and databases and examples of places where information is not necessarily reliable. I will explain what constitutes a credible source.

Lesson:
-Students will choose a topic of interest to research. This could be a famous person, a medical condition, a historic event, etc.
-Students will visit a variety of websites and databases to collect information regarding their topic.
-Students will analyze this information for accuracy and note any inconsistencies or questionable information.
-Students will report their findings to the class.
-*This assignment will be done as a precursor to writing a major research paper. Since the point of this assignment is simply to get students thinking about credible sources, the topic they choose could be anything and the format that they present the information is informal.

Assessment:
-I will use a rubric to score students based on how many websites they visited and analyzed. The rubric will also assess students’ ability to share their findings with the class.

5 comments:

  1. I think both of these assignments are a good idea; I have actually considered having my students create blogs next year for all of their writing assignments. It would cut down on paper and 8th Grade handwriting issues!

    Also, the second assignment, about credible sources, can't be emphasized enough. Each year I do a research project related to Anne Frank. Every year, when we get to finding sources, the first stop is Wikipedia. The librarian and I try to make the point that, although Wikipedia is a quick source, it isn't necessarily the most factual source because anyone can change entries. This second lesson could help make that point.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Great ideas! I had students maintain blogs this Spring, so I have a few pieces of advice if you haven't done classroom blogs before.

    Make the set up of blogs as simple as possible. I used blogger, but it was a nightmare because of all the security codes you have to type in. Check edublogs, it might be easier.

    Have ALL STUDENTS write down their log-in info, password, and blog URL (they will not know what a URL is) on an index card for YOU to keep. I can't remember how many times students had to restart their blogs because they could not figure out the log-in information.

    Be very clear on what you expect for the postings and for the commenting on postings. I had students sign a code of conduct saying that they'll refrain from harassment, foul language, etc. Discuss with them what makes a good comment on a blog, otherwise they will just say "that's cool".

    My last piece of advice is that ELL students tend to have the most difficulty with the blogs. If you have quite a few ELL students you may have to spend some extra time with them on what a blog is, and give them lots of structure to the postings.

    Even though it was a lot of work, I would definitely keep doing blogs with my students.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Steph, you point out something very interesting that I argue we haven't talked about enough in this class - teaching students that we don't only consume media material, but create material with which others consume. Although this is indeed a critical piece of Beach's rationale for teaching this kind of material, I don't think it's something we've stressed enough.

    Second, you mention that students will "post on the class blog." So am I understanding that this blog will be set up so that any student can edit / contribute to it? I ask because such a set up is extremely different than what we have been exposed to in this class - unless I give someone my log in information, no one is manipulating my blog but me. Do you think this different type of authorship will change anything, if at all? Do you think it might change how students approach the blog? Their assignments?

    I ask because I'm really not sure, this idea of co-authorship is very interesting to me, and I wished we would have talked more about it.

    Great work.

    -Rick

    ReplyDelete
  4. Hey Steph,

    Thank you for the credible sources assignment. Oh, please - please teach it/use it. I had a student (Basil) try and give me all these "facts" about Swine Flu he had breezed over on a Yahoo! answers site. It broke my heart. I had to explain to him that those were just people ("anyone!") out there in cyberspace posting their unfounded opinions... he said: "yeah, well...it looks legit."

    Our standards our dropping fastidiously due to the Internet and it is crucial to keep up on citations and what our primary sources are.

    Cheers!

    -Joe

    ReplyDelete
  5. Steph!!

    I think the credible sources assignment is so valuable for any classroom! Even in today's age where everything is found online, I find that students still have trouble distinguishing between what is fact and what is opinion, especially credible opinion. I agree with Joe as well, as fast as things change and as more and more students rely on the Internet versus the library (sigh) for information, we need to help them distinguish what is reliable and what isn't.

    Pi Phi Love. :) --Kim

    ReplyDelete